Skip to content

Trust The Science, Trust the science, trust the science . . . | “Hindawi and Wiley to retract over 500 papers linked to peer review rings” | Retraction Watch

‘After months of investigation that identified networks of reviewers and editors manipulating the peer review process, Hindawi plans to retract 511 papers across 16 journals, Retraction Watch has learned.

The retractions, which the publisher and its parent company, Wiley, will announce tomorrow in a blog post, will be issued in the next month, and more may come as its investigation continues. They are not yet making the list available.

Hindawi’s research integrity team found several signs of manipulated peer reviews for the affected papers, including reviews that contained duplicated text, a few individuals who did a lot of reviews, reviewers who turned in their reviews extremely quickly, and misuse of databases that publishers use to vet potential reviewers.

Richard Bennett, vice president of researcher and publishing services for Hindawi, told us that the publisher suspects “coordinated peer review rings” consisting of reviewers and editors working together to advance manuscripts through to publication. Some of the manuscripts appeared to come from paper mills, he said.

We asked what prompted the investigation. Bennett told us:

In April 2022, Hindawi’s Research Integrity team led an initial investigation into a single Special Issue (SI) after a Chief Editor raised concerns about some of the papers published in it. The team decided to investigate the content of the journal further. Through this investigation, the team highlighted a pattern of irregular and concerning reviewer activity and identified potential ‘bad actors’ that were present across many of these publications.

These concerns prompted the Publishing Insights and Research Integrity teams, enabled by recently enhanced analytic capabilities and newly developed dashboards providing views across all reviewer activity, to conduct a wider investigation to determine whether these same bad actors were involved in peer review manipulation elsewhere in the Hindawi portfolio.

Following the discovery that these bad actors were present in other journals, the Hindawi leadership team put in place a cross-functional working team combining the manual and data-driven investigation which resulted in the identification of further published articles.

In early August, Hindawi expanded the investigation under a combined investigation team comprising Research Integrity experts, data and analytics experts, publishing and operational teams, and legal counsel from both Wiley and Hindawi. This team evaluated in depth review activity across all potentially impacted articles and manuscripts. This resulted in a list of ‘compromised’ reviewers and editors in addition to the bad actors already discovered, identification of networks that exist between them, patterns of review activity, and insight into published articles and manuscripts at each stage in the review process that we could initially label as ‘compromised’. On September 6, the combined investigation team began assessing published articles which led to the initial recommendation to retract 511 articles that are compromised based on reviewer activity alone. We expect ongoing investigations to result in further retractions.’

 Exclusive: Hindawi and Wiley to retract over 500 papers linked to peer review rings | Retraction Watch

Skip The Scoop | Seek Understanding

May 4, 2021 | Nightly News Rebroadcast | Video: 52 Minutes 29 Seconds

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Morning Edition Hour 1 | Recorded May 4, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 40 Seconds

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Morning Edition Hour 2 | Recorded May 4, 2021 | Video: 47 Minutes 37 Seconds

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Evening Edition | Recorded May 4, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 59 Seconds

Show Me

Reaching ‘Herd Immunity’ Is Unlikely in the U.S., Experts Now Believe

Show Me

As Global Pandemic Worsens, U.S. Keeps Blocking Vaccine Patent Waivers Amid Big Pharma Lobbying

Show Me

Kansas Legislature Overrides Governor’s Veto, Bans the Election Zuck Bucks. Plus: A Win for 2A Rights.

Show Me

(READ) Trump statement on “The Big Lie”

Show Me

Cheney slams Trump on ‘big lie’ over election

Show Me

Zuckerberg and George W. Bush Partner in Far Left Immigration Push.

Show Me

MS-13 Gang Member Nicknamed ‘Terror’ Gets Life In Jail for Killing Texas Teen

Show Me

Judicial Watch: Records Show Iowa State Officials Coordinated with Big Tech to Censor Election Posts

Show Me

Facebook oversight board to reveal decision on Trump ban on Wednesday

Show Me

Gray Television to be second largest broadcaster after $2.7B Meredith deal

Show Me

Modi Resists Pressure to Lock Down India as Virus Deaths Rise

Show Me

Sen. Scott ‘Hopeful’ on Police Reform as Democrats Now Looking for ‘Solution,’ Not ‘Issue’

Show Me

Verizon Agrees to Sell Yahoo, AOL to Apollo for $5 Billion

Show Me

May 3, 2021 | Nightly News Rebroadcast | Video: 52 Minutes 29 Seconds

Show Me

Trump Lawyer Jenna Ellis Challenges Liz Cheney to Debate on 2020 Election Integrity: ‘Name the Time and Place’

Show Me

Hillary Clinton voices concern on Biden’s Afghanistan withdrawal, warns of ‘unintended’ consequences

Show Me

New York area will lift capacity restrictions May 19

Show Me

Walgreens launching mobile clinics, walk-in COVID-19 vaccinations

Show Me

Austin residents vote to ban homeless encampments

Show Me

Denmark Ditches J&J COVID Vaccine, Says Benefits ‘Do Not Outweigh Risk’ of Blood Clots

Show Me

Florida Gov. DeSantis Suspends Local COVID-19 Emergency Orders, Bans Vaccine Passports

Show Me

The ‘Left’ Has Learned, The Quickest Way To Shut Down Your Opponent’s Objections Is To Call Them A ‘Racist’ | Just Ask ‘Minorities’ | “GOP Whip Montoya Blasts ‘race-baiting’ In Session”

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Morning Edition Hour 1 | Recorded May 3, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 24 Seconds

Show Me

Anti-Woke Faction Opposed To Critical Race Theory Wins Texas School Board Race

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Morning Edition Hour 2 | Recorded May 3, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 16 Seconds

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Evening Edition | Recorded May 3, 2021 | Video: 40 Minutes 16 Seconds

Show Me

ADL’s Official Stance On Israel | “Support Israel: A Jewish and Democratic State”

Show Me

John Kerry Threatens Israel With Boycotts (2014)

Show Me

Former Security Adviser: John Kerry Undermined Trump in Unapproved Iran Talks

Show Me

ADL To Kerry: ‘Your Threats Destroy Peace Talks’ (2014)

Show Me

Apparently, Human Rights Watch Disagrees With ADL’s Stance On Israel | Video: 3 Minutes

Show Me

Gov. Abbott praised by Anti-Defamation League over racist posts by GOP leaders in Texas

Show Me

Texas GOP Chairman Allen West Joins Gab After Party Takes Account Down

Show Me

Could We Soon See Liz Cheney Gone from Leadership?

Show Me

Hubble Watches How a Giant Planet Grows

Show Me

Fake News: New York Times, WaPo, NBC forced to retract false claims about Giuliani

Show Me