Skip to content

Rumble and Law Professor Sue New York Attorney General to Block Online Hate Speech Law, Calling It a First Amendment ‘Double Whammy’ | Law & Crime

Two days before New York’s online hate speech law is supposed to take effect, the video-sharing website Rumble and a law professor filed a lawsuit against New York Attorney General Letitia James (D) asking a judge to call it vague and unconstitutional.

Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, a non-profit group better known by its acronym FIRE, filed the 46-page complaint on behalf of three plaintiffs: Rumble, the crowd funding site Locals, and Eugene Volokh, the First Amendment scholar behind the legal blog The Volokh Conspiracy.

“New York politicians are slapping a speech-police badge on my chest because I run a blog,” Volokh wrote in a statement. “I started the blog to share interesting and important legal stories, not to police readers’ speech at the government’s behest.”

Passed in the wake of a white supremacist’s mass shooting of Black shoppers at a grocery story in Buffalo, New York, the law forces social media networks to publish a policy explaining how they will clamp down on speech perceived to “vilify, humiliate, or incite violence against a group or class of persons” based on race, color, religion, or other protected categories. FIRE notes that those platforms will be required to create a mechanism to report such speech — and must respond to those complaints.

In their complaint, Volokh’s lawyers say that the law “hangs like the Sword of Damocles over a broad swath of online services.”

“In something of a First Amendment ‘double whammy,’ the Online Hate Speech Law burdens the publication of disfavored but protected speech through unconstitutionally compelled speech — forcing online services to single out ‘hate speech’ with a dedicated policy, a mandatory report & response mechanism, and obligatory direct replies to each report,” the professor’s lawyer Darapana M. Sheth writes in the complaint. “If a service refuses, the law threatens New York Attorney General investigations, subpoenas, and daily fines of $1,000 per violation.”

Earlier this week, Buffalo mass shooter Payton Gendron pleaded guilty to all 25 state charges leveled against him for his terrorist attack, which he live-streamed via a GoPro that he wore to the mass slaughter. He disseminated a racist rant before his shooting spree that articulated his motives, like other white supremacists before him in Christchurch, New Zealand, and elsewhere.

The Empire State law had been intended, in part, to keep racially motivated terrorists from having spaces online to spread their ideologies and stop copycat attacks.

But Volokh says that the New York law goes too far, using such broad language that any attorney general can put bloggers at risk of financial ruin, if commenters share opinions that are disfavored by the state.

Under his interpretation of the statute, the professor says that regulators can go after an atheist perceived to have “vilified” organized religion — or comedian John Oliver for his recent segment on HBO’s Last Week Tonight sending up the British monarchy, which could be construed as a “humiliation” of the U.K.

“There can be no reasonable doubt New York will enforce the Online Hate Speech Law to strong-arm online services into censoring protected speech,” the complaint states. “The Attorney General’s intentions, in fact, could not be clearer; as recited, for example, in an October press release, the Attorney General declared that ‘[o]nline platforms should be held accountable for allowing hateful and dangerous content to spread on their platforms’ because an alleged ‘lack of oversight, transparency, and accountability of these platforms allows hateful and extremist views to proliferate online.’”

Rumble, Locals and Volokh want a federal judge to declare the law unconstitutional on its face as “vague” and “overbroad.” They also seek to a declaration that it runs afoul of Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, a statute that has come under fire by politicians across the political spectrum. . . .

Rumble and Law Professor Sue New York Attorney General to Block Online Hate Speech Law, Calling It a First Amendment ‘Double Whammy’ | Law & Crime

Skip The Scoop | Seek Understanding

May 4, 2021 | Nightly News Rebroadcast | Video: 52 Minutes 29 Seconds

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Morning Edition Hour 1 | Recorded May 4, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 40 Seconds

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Morning Edition Hour 2 | Recorded May 4, 2021 | Video: 47 Minutes 37 Seconds

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Evening Edition | Recorded May 4, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 59 Seconds

Show Me

Reaching ‘Herd Immunity’ Is Unlikely in the U.S., Experts Now Believe

Show Me

As Global Pandemic Worsens, U.S. Keeps Blocking Vaccine Patent Waivers Amid Big Pharma Lobbying

Show Me

Kansas Legislature Overrides Governor’s Veto, Bans the Election Zuck Bucks. Plus: A Win for 2A Rights.

Show Me

(READ) Trump statement on “The Big Lie”

Show Me

Cheney slams Trump on ‘big lie’ over election

Show Me

Zuckerberg and George W. Bush Partner in Far Left Immigration Push.

Show Me

MS-13 Gang Member Nicknamed ‘Terror’ Gets Life In Jail for Killing Texas Teen

Show Me

Judicial Watch: Records Show Iowa State Officials Coordinated with Big Tech to Censor Election Posts

Show Me

Facebook oversight board to reveal decision on Trump ban on Wednesday

Show Me

Gray Television to be second largest broadcaster after $2.7B Meredith deal

Show Me

Modi Resists Pressure to Lock Down India as Virus Deaths Rise

Show Me

Sen. Scott ‘Hopeful’ on Police Reform as Democrats Now Looking for ‘Solution,’ Not ‘Issue’

Show Me

Verizon Agrees to Sell Yahoo, AOL to Apollo for $5 Billion

Show Me

May 3, 2021 | Nightly News Rebroadcast | Video: 52 Minutes 29 Seconds

Show Me

Trump Lawyer Jenna Ellis Challenges Liz Cheney to Debate on 2020 Election Integrity: ‘Name the Time and Place’

Show Me

Hillary Clinton voices concern on Biden’s Afghanistan withdrawal, warns of ‘unintended’ consequences

Show Me

New York area will lift capacity restrictions May 19

Show Me

Walgreens launching mobile clinics, walk-in COVID-19 vaccinations

Show Me

Austin residents vote to ban homeless encampments

Show Me

Denmark Ditches J&J COVID Vaccine, Says Benefits ‘Do Not Outweigh Risk’ of Blood Clots

Show Me

Florida Gov. DeSantis Suspends Local COVID-19 Emergency Orders, Bans Vaccine Passports

Show Me

The ‘Left’ Has Learned, The Quickest Way To Shut Down Your Opponent’s Objections Is To Call Them A ‘Racist’ | Just Ask ‘Minorities’ | “GOP Whip Montoya Blasts ‘race-baiting’ In Session”

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Morning Edition Hour 1 | Recorded May 3, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 24 Seconds

Show Me

Anti-Woke Faction Opposed To Critical Race Theory Wins Texas School Board Race

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Morning Edition Hour 2 | Recorded May 3, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 16 Seconds

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Evening Edition | Recorded May 3, 2021 | Video: 40 Minutes 16 Seconds

Show Me

ADL’s Official Stance On Israel | “Support Israel: A Jewish and Democratic State”

Show Me

John Kerry Threatens Israel With Boycotts (2014)

Show Me

Former Security Adviser: John Kerry Undermined Trump in Unapproved Iran Talks

Show Me

ADL To Kerry: ‘Your Threats Destroy Peace Talks’ (2014)

Show Me

Apparently, Human Rights Watch Disagrees With ADL’s Stance On Israel | Video: 3 Minutes

Show Me

Gov. Abbott praised by Anti-Defamation League over racist posts by GOP leaders in Texas

Show Me

Texas GOP Chairman Allen West Joins Gab After Party Takes Account Down

Show Me

Could We Soon See Liz Cheney Gone from Leadership?

Show Me

Hubble Watches How a Giant Planet Grows

Show Me

Fake News: New York Times, WaPo, NBC forced to retract false claims about Giuliani

Show Me