Skip to content

Utah Was Warned Racial Rationing of COVID Drugs Was Illegal. It Did It Anyway. | The Washington Free Beacon

Utah public health officials were warned that allocating COVID drugs based on race violated federal law, but did so anyway with the backing of the Biden administration, emails and documents obtained by the Washington Free Beacon show.

Utah’s points-based system for prioritizing COVID patients, which allocated more points for being non-white than for having congestive heart failure, troubled two law professors specializing in bioethics. They informed the doctors who designed the system in September 2021 that it was probably illegal.

“The use of non-white race really set off alarm bells,” Teneille Brown, a professor at the University of Utah’s S.J. Quinney College of Law, said in an email.

The “consensus among legal academics,” Brown’s colleague Leslie Francis added, is that a system like Utah’s would “violate federal law.”

This piece is based on materials obtained via a third-party public records request and shared with the Free Beacon.

The doctors Brown and Francis emailed were part of the state’s Crisis Standards of Care workgroup, assembled by the Utah Hospital Association at the behest of the health department. When COVID surged in November 2020, the health department asked the group to develop a system for allocating scarce therapies. The group conceded its approach hadn’t been “reviewed legally.” But, they assured the law professors, it did have the blessing of the Biden administration.

The Department of Health and Human Services “has lauded our approach,” said Mark Shah, the director of Utah’s Disaster Medical Assistance Team and a member of the group. In February 2021, Shah’s colleague Brandon Webb presented the race-based allocation system to HHS, according to power point slides reviewed by the Free Beacon. HHS subsequently listed the system as a “promising practice” for other states to consider.

Such race-conscious policies proliferated throughout the pandemic, sparking both moral outrage and legal scrutiny. Like Utah, Minnesota and New York prioritized non-white residents for moncolonal antibodies. Vermont did the same for vaccines. Some states, including Utah and Minnesota, scrapped their policies in the wake of political backlash—and amid threats of legal action from conservative nonprofits.

The emails suggest Utah was ground zero for many of these schemes. The state initially defended its system by invoking guidance from the Food and Drug Administration, which lists race as a risk factor that can qualify patients for monoclonal antibodies. But according to the emails, it was Utah that inspired that guidance in the first place.

“The FDA reviewed our Utah Risk Score and used it as precedent for including ‘race and other risk factors’ as qualifiers,” Shah told the group in June 2021. Minnesota in turn used that precedent to justify its own allocation system.

The emails reflect the race-conscious consensus that has taken hold of medical bureaucracies across the country. As that consensus has consolidated at every level of government, it has emboldened public health officials to flout anti-discrimination law, which they assume won’t be enforced.

The gap between law and policy widened with the pandemic, which provided an emergency pretext for suspending civil rights. Nondiscrimination, the emails suggest, was seen as an obstacle to crisis management.

“I’d prefer just using the ‘we’re too busy trying to save lives during the surge’ excuse,” Webb, an infectious diseases specialist at Intermountain Healthcare, emailed his colleagues after some back and forth with the law professors.

That utilitarian mindset extended to Utah’s Republican governor Spencer Cox, who in January 2022 told health officials to modify the allocation system, a spokesperson for the governor said—but only after it became clear that the drugs weren’t reaching minorities. The problem wasn’t that the system discriminated by race; it was that the discrimination didn’t work.

“Despite the inclusion of race and ethnicity,” the spokesperson told the Free Beacon, “communities of color did not receive monoclonal antibodies proportionate to their share of COVID-test positives.”

“I’m frankly surprised that this has not yet been subject to a legal challenge,” Webb wrote the law professors. He added that in 2020, the group asked “the Office of Civil Rights” for guidance on the use of race but didn’t receive a response.

It is unclear to which office Webb was referring. A draft copy of the group’s inquiry includes no date or letterhead, and Roger Severino, HHS’s director of civil rights at the time, said it never came across his desk.

“Had this been brought to my attention,” Severino told the Free Beacon, “I would have told them they risked violating Title VI and would have merited my office investigating them had they gone through with such explicit race based rationing.”

Reached for comment, Webb said Shah was the one who sent the inquiry. Shah did not respond to a request for comment.

The group, which developed the system in November 2020, took for granted that all racial minorities should receive special treatment. It borrowed heavily from an allocation system used by the Cleveland Clinic, which prioritized African Americans for monoclonal antibodies. The “only knock” against that system, Webb wrote the group, is that “it only gives disparity weighting to black race rather than recognizing elevated risk associated with other race/ethnicities.”

Utah’s system was based on an analysis of 20,000 COVID patients between March and October 2020. Though some minorities are at higher risk than others, according to the state’s own data, the analysis lumped all of them together, comparing hospitalization rates between “white” and “non-white” Utahns.

The result was a “risk score calculator” that gave “non-white race or Hispanic/Latinx ethnicity” two points—more than it gave hypertension, chronic kidney disease, or shortness of breath. Utahns needed to score a certain number of points to be eligible for monoclonal antibodies.

The calculator was first used by the Intermountain hospital system, which employed many members of the group, including Webb and Shah. By September 2021, it was causing controversy among COVID-stricken patients.

“We have been forced into a defense of the scoring system as now constituents are reaching out to elected leaders asking why they are not eligible,” lamented Kevin McCulley, the Preparedness and Response director for the health department.

As pushback mounted, the department’s main concern was semantic rather than substantive. Officials spent days wordsmithing an online “self-screening tool” based on the calculator, in part to ensure it didn’t run afoul of progressive sensibilities.

“Latinex should have the ‘e’ removed (Latinx),” Matthew Plendl, a member of the health department, said of an early draft.

Some exchanges read like parodies of progressive racecraft, with officials attempting to sort out who would count as “non-white.”

The calculator lets “someone select more than one race category,” noted Jenny Johnson, a member of the health department’s communications team. “Would this mean anyone who marks ONLY White would not meet the criteria? And those who mark at least one race category that is not White does meet the criteria?”

Particularly vexing was the status of Hispanics.

“Someone with a high level of cultural competence should help us wordsmith this,” McCulley wrote his colleagues. “Is your race Non-white or Hispanic/Latinex Ethnicity? I don’t think Hispanic is a race.”

The post Utah Was Warned Racial Rationing of COVID Drugs Was Illegal. It Did It Anyway. appeared first on Washington Free Beacon.

Skip The Scoop | Seek Understanding

Facebook oversight board member rips social media giant as ‘inconsistent’ after Trump ban

Show Me

Utah County Censures Mitt Romney for Trump Impeachment Vote

Show Me

A Majority of Americans Support ‘Vaccine Passports’ for Some Activities, Poll Finds

Show Me

There Are Simple Reasons Liz Cheney Has To Go

Show Me

Scarlett Johansson urges boycott of ‘sexist’ Golden Globes unless organizers implement major reforms

Show Me

Biden’s new left of racial radicals: Goodwin

Show Me

Establishment Media Still Fixated on Donald Trump Four Months After Office

Show Me

Asian Parents Rally Against NYC Schools Chancellor

Show Me

Gordon Chang: Communist China Has Committed ‘Mass Murder’ of Americans

Show Me

Success Academy requiring all employees get vaccinated for COVID-19

Show Me

Lockdown ‘has helped to rot kids’ teeth’: Number of children with dental decay is set to soar

Show Me

As A Mother Grows

Show Me

Here’s How You Know Democrats Rigged and Stole the 2020 Election

Show Me

Nearly 9 out of 10 young adults want a Covid inoculation, survey finds 

Show Me

Minnesota gets creative in COVID-19 vaccine outreach

Show Me

Apparently, We See Once Again Everyone Is Vulnerable Except Dominion Voting Systems | “Ransomware Attackers Up Ante as White House Vows Crack Down”

Show Me

With Trump On The Sidelines & Biden In | “Jerusalem sees second night of clashes as Israeli security forces block Muslim pilgrims at mosque”

Show Me

Astronomers observe black hole ‘spaghettification’ of a star for the first time

Show Me

Arizona Formally Bans Post-Election Signature Fix for Unsigned Mail-In Ballots

Show Me

Trump planned Qassem Soleimani’s assassination from 2017 and wanted to wipe out a ‘list of folks’

Show Me

Feminist Author Naomi Wolf: Democrats Are ‘In An Embrace With Big Tech’ To ‘Consolidate Power’ | Video: 5 Minutes 1 Second

Show Me

POLICE STATE: Watch the moment a SWAT team arrests a Canadian pastor | Video: 2 Minutes 58 Seconds

Show Me

UMass Amherst students suspended for partying outside without masks

Show Me

From Peaceniks of 1960s to the Social Justice Warriors of 2020s: Some Cultural and Spiritual Insights

Show Me

Pope Francis Calls for ‘Temporary Suspension’ of Property Rights to Vaccines During ‘Vax Live’ Concert

Show Me

Violent Crime Surged in These Cities After Mass Black Lives Matter, Anti-Police Protests

Show Me

Gwyneth Paltrow drank whiskey ‘every night’ during COVID-19 lockdown

Show Me

The Civics Secures Democracy Act Is a Neo-Marxist Trojan Horse

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Saturday Edition Hour 1 | Recorded May 8, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 23 Seconds

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Saturday Edition Hour 2 | Recorded May 8, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 18 Seconds

Show Me

CDC Changes Rules for Counting Breakthrough Cases, as More Fully Vaccinated People Test Positive

Show Me

Woman In Mali Expecting Seven Babies Gives Birth To Nine

Show Me

Hundreds Of Children Were Shot In 2020 and Into 2021. Many Of Their Assailants Have Not Been Caught

Show Me

Exclusive—Josh Hawley Keeps His Children off Social Media: ‘Their Business Model Is Addiction’

Show Me

Rutgers to enroll 200 kids to take part in Pfizer COVID vaccine trial

Show Me

Apparently, Only Americans Are To Be Stalked By U.S. Government ‘Leaders’ | “Biden Order Rescinds Trump Plan to Collect Facial Scans, DNA From Immigrants”

Show Me

Krista Kafer: Will vaccine requirements set precedent we will regret?

Show Me

In-person school should be ‘mandatory’ for CPS students in the fall, CPS CEO says (Chicago)

Show Me

WATCH: Michelle Obama Claims That Black Lives Matter is ‘Taking to the Streets Because They Have To’

Show Me

More than 2,100 migrant children abandoned relatives to cross border alone after Biden took office

Show Me