Skip to content

Trust The Science, Trust the science, trust the science . . . | “Hindawi and Wiley to retract over 500 papers linked to peer review rings” | Retraction Watch

‘After months of investigation that identified networks of reviewers and editors manipulating the peer review process, Hindawi plans to retract 511 papers across 16 journals, Retraction Watch has learned.

The retractions, which the publisher and its parent company, Wiley, will announce tomorrow in a blog post, will be issued in the next month, and more may come as its investigation continues. They are not yet making the list available.

Hindawi’s research integrity team found several signs of manipulated peer reviews for the affected papers, including reviews that contained duplicated text, a few individuals who did a lot of reviews, reviewers who turned in their reviews extremely quickly, and misuse of databases that publishers use to vet potential reviewers.

Richard Bennett, vice president of researcher and publishing services for Hindawi, told us that the publisher suspects “coordinated peer review rings” consisting of reviewers and editors working together to advance manuscripts through to publication. Some of the manuscripts appeared to come from paper mills, he said.

We asked what prompted the investigation. Bennett told us:

In April 2022, Hindawi’s Research Integrity team led an initial investigation into a single Special Issue (SI) after a Chief Editor raised concerns about some of the papers published in it. The team decided to investigate the content of the journal further. Through this investigation, the team highlighted a pattern of irregular and concerning reviewer activity and identified potential ‘bad actors’ that were present across many of these publications.

These concerns prompted the Publishing Insights and Research Integrity teams, enabled by recently enhanced analytic capabilities and newly developed dashboards providing views across all reviewer activity, to conduct a wider investigation to determine whether these same bad actors were involved in peer review manipulation elsewhere in the Hindawi portfolio.

Following the discovery that these bad actors were present in other journals, the Hindawi leadership team put in place a cross-functional working team combining the manual and data-driven investigation which resulted in the identification of further published articles.

In early August, Hindawi expanded the investigation under a combined investigation team comprising Research Integrity experts, data and analytics experts, publishing and operational teams, and legal counsel from both Wiley and Hindawi. This team evaluated in depth review activity across all potentially impacted articles and manuscripts. This resulted in a list of ‘compromised’ reviewers and editors in addition to the bad actors already discovered, identification of networks that exist between them, patterns of review activity, and insight into published articles and manuscripts at each stage in the review process that we could initially label as ‘compromised’. On September 6, the combined investigation team began assessing published articles which led to the initial recommendation to retract 511 articles that are compromised based on reviewer activity alone. We expect ongoing investigations to result in further retractions.’

 Exclusive: Hindawi and Wiley to retract over 500 papers linked to peer review rings | Retraction Watch

Skip The Scoop | Seek Understanding

Facebook oversight board member rips social media giant as ‘inconsistent’ after Trump ban

Show Me

Utah County Censures Mitt Romney for Trump Impeachment Vote

Show Me

A Majority of Americans Support ‘Vaccine Passports’ for Some Activities, Poll Finds

Show Me

There Are Simple Reasons Liz Cheney Has To Go

Show Me

Scarlett Johansson urges boycott of ‘sexist’ Golden Globes unless organizers implement major reforms

Show Me

Biden’s new left of racial radicals: Goodwin

Show Me

Establishment Media Still Fixated on Donald Trump Four Months After Office

Show Me

Asian Parents Rally Against NYC Schools Chancellor

Show Me

Gordon Chang: Communist China Has Committed ‘Mass Murder’ of Americans

Show Me

Success Academy requiring all employees get vaccinated for COVID-19

Show Me

Lockdown ‘has helped to rot kids’ teeth’: Number of children with dental decay is set to soar

Show Me

As A Mother Grows

Show Me

Here’s How You Know Democrats Rigged and Stole the 2020 Election

Show Me

Nearly 9 out of 10 young adults want a Covid inoculation, survey finds 

Show Me

Minnesota gets creative in COVID-19 vaccine outreach

Show Me

Apparently, We See Once Again Everyone Is Vulnerable Except Dominion Voting Systems | “Ransomware Attackers Up Ante as White House Vows Crack Down”

Show Me

With Trump On The Sidelines & Biden In | “Jerusalem sees second night of clashes as Israeli security forces block Muslim pilgrims at mosque”

Show Me

Astronomers observe black hole ‘spaghettification’ of a star for the first time

Show Me

Arizona Formally Bans Post-Election Signature Fix for Unsigned Mail-In Ballots

Show Me

Trump planned Qassem Soleimani’s assassination from 2017 and wanted to wipe out a ‘list of folks’

Show Me

Feminist Author Naomi Wolf: Democrats Are ‘In An Embrace With Big Tech’ To ‘Consolidate Power’ | Video: 5 Minutes 1 Second

Show Me

POLICE STATE: Watch the moment a SWAT team arrests a Canadian pastor | Video: 2 Minutes 58 Seconds

Show Me

UMass Amherst students suspended for partying outside without masks

Show Me

From Peaceniks of 1960s to the Social Justice Warriors of 2020s: Some Cultural and Spiritual Insights

Show Me

Pope Francis Calls for ‘Temporary Suspension’ of Property Rights to Vaccines During ‘Vax Live’ Concert

Show Me

Violent Crime Surged in These Cities After Mass Black Lives Matter, Anti-Police Protests

Show Me

Gwyneth Paltrow drank whiskey ‘every night’ during COVID-19 lockdown

Show Me

The Civics Secures Democracy Act Is a Neo-Marxist Trojan Horse

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Saturday Edition Hour 1 | Recorded May 8, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 23 Seconds

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Saturday Edition Hour 2 | Recorded May 8, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 18 Seconds

Show Me

CDC Changes Rules for Counting Breakthrough Cases, as More Fully Vaccinated People Test Positive

Show Me

Woman In Mali Expecting Seven Babies Gives Birth To Nine

Show Me

Hundreds Of Children Were Shot In 2020 and Into 2021. Many Of Their Assailants Have Not Been Caught

Show Me

Exclusive—Josh Hawley Keeps His Children off Social Media: ‘Their Business Model Is Addiction’

Show Me

Rutgers to enroll 200 kids to take part in Pfizer COVID vaccine trial

Show Me

Apparently, Only Americans Are To Be Stalked By U.S. Government ‘Leaders’ | “Biden Order Rescinds Trump Plan to Collect Facial Scans, DNA From Immigrants”

Show Me

Krista Kafer: Will vaccine requirements set precedent we will regret?

Show Me

In-person school should be ‘mandatory’ for CPS students in the fall, CPS CEO says (Chicago)

Show Me

WATCH: Michelle Obama Claims That Black Lives Matter is ‘Taking to the Streets Because They Have To’

Show Me

More than 2,100 migrant children abandoned relatives to cross border alone after Biden took office

Show Me