Skip to content

Rumble and Law Professor Sue New York Attorney General to Block Online Hate Speech Law, Calling It a First Amendment ‘Double Whammy’ | Law & Crime

Two days before New York’s online hate speech law is supposed to take effect, the video-sharing website Rumble and a law professor filed a lawsuit against New York Attorney General Letitia James (D) asking a judge to call it vague and unconstitutional.

Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, a non-profit group better known by its acronym FIRE, filed the 46-page complaint on behalf of three plaintiffs: Rumble, the crowd funding site Locals, and Eugene Volokh, the First Amendment scholar behind the legal blog The Volokh Conspiracy.

“New York politicians are slapping a speech-police badge on my chest because I run a blog,” Volokh wrote in a statement. “I started the blog to share interesting and important legal stories, not to police readers’ speech at the government’s behest.”

Passed in the wake of a white supremacist’s mass shooting of Black shoppers at a grocery story in Buffalo, New York, the law forces social media networks to publish a policy explaining how they will clamp down on speech perceived to “vilify, humiliate, or incite violence against a group or class of persons” based on race, color, religion, or other protected categories. FIRE notes that those platforms will be required to create a mechanism to report such speech — and must respond to those complaints.

In their complaint, Volokh’s lawyers say that the law “hangs like the Sword of Damocles over a broad swath of online services.”

“In something of a First Amendment ‘double whammy,’ the Online Hate Speech Law burdens the publication of disfavored but protected speech through unconstitutionally compelled speech — forcing online services to single out ‘hate speech’ with a dedicated policy, a mandatory report & response mechanism, and obligatory direct replies to each report,” the professor’s lawyer Darapana M. Sheth writes in the complaint. “If a service refuses, the law threatens New York Attorney General investigations, subpoenas, and daily fines of $1,000 per violation.”

Earlier this week, Buffalo mass shooter Payton Gendron pleaded guilty to all 25 state charges leveled against him for his terrorist attack, which he live-streamed via a GoPro that he wore to the mass slaughter. He disseminated a racist rant before his shooting spree that articulated his motives, like other white supremacists before him in Christchurch, New Zealand, and elsewhere.

The Empire State law had been intended, in part, to keep racially motivated terrorists from having spaces online to spread their ideologies and stop copycat attacks.

But Volokh says that the New York law goes too far, using such broad language that any attorney general can put bloggers at risk of financial ruin, if commenters share opinions that are disfavored by the state.

Under his interpretation of the statute, the professor says that regulators can go after an atheist perceived to have “vilified” organized religion — or comedian John Oliver for his recent segment on HBO’s Last Week Tonight sending up the British monarchy, which could be construed as a “humiliation” of the U.K.

“There can be no reasonable doubt New York will enforce the Online Hate Speech Law to strong-arm online services into censoring protected speech,” the complaint states. “The Attorney General’s intentions, in fact, could not be clearer; as recited, for example, in an October press release, the Attorney General declared that ‘[o]nline platforms should be held accountable for allowing hateful and dangerous content to spread on their platforms’ because an alleged ‘lack of oversight, transparency, and accountability of these platforms allows hateful and extremist views to proliferate online.’”

Rumble, Locals and Volokh want a federal judge to declare the law unconstitutional on its face as “vague” and “overbroad.” They also seek to a declaration that it runs afoul of Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, a statute that has come under fire by politicians across the political spectrum. . . .

Rumble and Law Professor Sue New York Attorney General to Block Online Hate Speech Law, Calling It a First Amendment ‘Double Whammy’ | Law & Crime

Skip The Scoop | Seek Understanding

Facebook oversight board member rips social media giant as ‘inconsistent’ after Trump ban

Show Me

Utah County Censures Mitt Romney for Trump Impeachment Vote

Show Me

A Majority of Americans Support ‘Vaccine Passports’ for Some Activities, Poll Finds

Show Me

There Are Simple Reasons Liz Cheney Has To Go

Show Me

Scarlett Johansson urges boycott of ‘sexist’ Golden Globes unless organizers implement major reforms

Show Me

Biden’s new left of racial radicals: Goodwin

Show Me

Establishment Media Still Fixated on Donald Trump Four Months After Office

Show Me

Asian Parents Rally Against NYC Schools Chancellor

Show Me

Gordon Chang: Communist China Has Committed ‘Mass Murder’ of Americans

Show Me

Success Academy requiring all employees get vaccinated for COVID-19

Show Me

Lockdown ‘has helped to rot kids’ teeth’: Number of children with dental decay is set to soar

Show Me

As A Mother Grows

Show Me

Here’s How You Know Democrats Rigged and Stole the 2020 Election

Show Me

Nearly 9 out of 10 young adults want a Covid inoculation, survey finds 

Show Me

Minnesota gets creative in COVID-19 vaccine outreach

Show Me

Apparently, We See Once Again Everyone Is Vulnerable Except Dominion Voting Systems | “Ransomware Attackers Up Ante as White House Vows Crack Down”

Show Me

With Trump On The Sidelines & Biden In | “Jerusalem sees second night of clashes as Israeli security forces block Muslim pilgrims at mosque”

Show Me

Astronomers observe black hole ‘spaghettification’ of a star for the first time

Show Me

Arizona Formally Bans Post-Election Signature Fix for Unsigned Mail-In Ballots

Show Me

Trump planned Qassem Soleimani’s assassination from 2017 and wanted to wipe out a ‘list of folks’

Show Me

Feminist Author Naomi Wolf: Democrats Are ‘In An Embrace With Big Tech’ To ‘Consolidate Power’ | Video: 5 Minutes 1 Second

Show Me

POLICE STATE: Watch the moment a SWAT team arrests a Canadian pastor | Video: 2 Minutes 58 Seconds

Show Me

UMass Amherst students suspended for partying outside without masks

Show Me

From Peaceniks of 1960s to the Social Justice Warriors of 2020s: Some Cultural and Spiritual Insights

Show Me

Pope Francis Calls for ‘Temporary Suspension’ of Property Rights to Vaccines During ‘Vax Live’ Concert

Show Me

Violent Crime Surged in These Cities After Mass Black Lives Matter, Anti-Police Protests

Show Me

Gwyneth Paltrow drank whiskey ‘every night’ during COVID-19 lockdown

Show Me

The Civics Secures Democracy Act Is a Neo-Marxist Trojan Horse

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Saturday Edition Hour 1 | Recorded May 8, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 23 Seconds

Show Me

Bannon’s War Room | Saturday Edition Hour 2 | Recorded May 8, 2021 | Video: 48 Minutes 18 Seconds

Show Me

CDC Changes Rules for Counting Breakthrough Cases, as More Fully Vaccinated People Test Positive

Show Me

Woman In Mali Expecting Seven Babies Gives Birth To Nine

Show Me

Hundreds Of Children Were Shot In 2020 and Into 2021. Many Of Their Assailants Have Not Been Caught

Show Me

Exclusive—Josh Hawley Keeps His Children off Social Media: ‘Their Business Model Is Addiction’

Show Me

Rutgers to enroll 200 kids to take part in Pfizer COVID vaccine trial

Show Me

Apparently, Only Americans Are To Be Stalked By U.S. Government ‘Leaders’ | “Biden Order Rescinds Trump Plan to Collect Facial Scans, DNA From Immigrants”

Show Me

Krista Kafer: Will vaccine requirements set precedent we will regret?

Show Me

In-person school should be ‘mandatory’ for CPS students in the fall, CPS CEO says (Chicago)

Show Me

WATCH: Michelle Obama Claims That Black Lives Matter is ‘Taking to the Streets Because They Have To’

Show Me

More than 2,100 migrant children abandoned relatives to cross border alone after Biden took office

Show Me